MOSBY, JOHN S. (1833-1916). ALS to Captain Samuel F. Chapman. Washington, DC, 28 March 1909. Mentioning the notorious former "Mosby Ranger" and traitor, Charles E. Binns.
Sale 1344 - American Historical Ephemera and Photography
May 31, 2024
10:00AM ET
Live / Cincinnati
Estimate
$500 -
$700
Sold for $762
Sold prices are inclusive of Buyer’s Premium
Lot Description
MOSBY, JOHN S. (1833-1916). ALS to Captain Samuel F. Chapman. Washington, DC, 28 March 1909. Mentioning the notorious former "Mosby Ranger" and traitor, Charles E. Binns.
One page, 8 x 10 1/2 in., old folds, ink staining/smearing, other staining/toning. On Department of Justice letterhead.
Mosby first asks his trusted correspondent "Sam" for the steamship schedule so that he can address a letter to someone named "Willie." He then turns to the subject of Charles E. Binns, an alleged deserter from Mosby's 43rd Virginia Cavalry Battalion, who Mosby simply refers to here as "Binns."
He writes: "Bringing up Binns alive before This generation does look a good deal like the resurrection of Cain. It was Welt Hatcher who was with Binns when he committed the outrage at Frank Rixley's. I suppose Cain wd. now deny that he ever committed murder. You see I have imposed on Binns the curse of the Wandering Jew - Immortality. A hundred years hence he will be roaming through Fairfax begging somebody to kill him."
Mosby served as an assistant attorney in the Federal Department of Justice from 1904-1910. When one of his former rangers, Dulaney Richards, died in January of 1909, Mosby penned a letter praising Richards and dogging his stepfather, Charles Binns, which was printed in the 22 February issues of the Fairfax Herald. When Binns replied to Mosby's published letter, an anonymous subject publicly accused Binns of being a deserter from Mosby's command.
Charles E. Binns, of Loudon County, joined up with Mosby's command in Middleburg along with his stepson Dulaney Richards. Binns had served with Mosby for about six months, when, according to James Williamson's Mosby's Rangers, he "committed some acts of rascality" while drunk. Mosby reportedly ordered Binns' arrest, and presumably to escape punishment, Binns deserted the command. He then offered his services as a scout and guide to Colonel Charles Russell Lowell, commander of the cavalry brigade of the Union XXII Corps. This act made Binns not only a deserter, but a much reviled turncoat.
Letter accompanied by a typewritten transcription.
Mosby first asks his trusted correspondent "Sam" for the steamship schedule so that he can address a letter to someone named "Willie." He then turns to the subject of Charles E. Binns, an alleged deserter from Mosby's 43rd Virginia Cavalry Battalion, who Mosby simply refers to here as "Binns."
He writes: "Bringing up Binns alive before This generation does look a good deal like the resurrection of Cain. It was Welt Hatcher who was with Binns when he committed the outrage at Frank Rixley's. I suppose Cain wd. now deny that he ever committed murder. You see I have imposed on Binns the curse of the Wandering Jew - Immortality. A hundred years hence he will be roaming through Fairfax begging somebody to kill him."
Mosby served as an assistant attorney in the Federal Department of Justice from 1904-1910. When one of his former rangers, Dulaney Richards, died in January of 1909, Mosby penned a letter praising Richards and dogging his stepfather, Charles Binns, which was printed in the 22 February issues of the Fairfax Herald. When Binns replied to Mosby's published letter, an anonymous subject publicly accused Binns of being a deserter from Mosby's command.
Charles E. Binns, of Loudon County, joined up with Mosby's command in Middleburg along with his stepson Dulaney Richards. Binns had served with Mosby for about six months, when, according to James Williamson's Mosby's Rangers, he "committed some acts of rascality" while drunk. Mosby reportedly ordered Binns' arrest, and presumably to escape punishment, Binns deserted the command. He then offered his services as a scout and guide to Colonel Charles Russell Lowell, commander of the cavalry brigade of the Union XXII Corps. This act made Binns not only a deserter, but a much reviled turncoat.
Letter accompanied by a typewritten transcription.
This lot is located in Cincinnati.
The John Singleton Mosby Collection of Hugh C. Keen
Condition Report
The physical condition of lots in our auctions can vary due to
age, normal wear and tear, previous damage, and
restoration/repair. All lots are sold "AS IS," in the condition
they are in at the time of the auction, and we and the seller make
no representation or warranty and assume no liability of any kind
as to a lot's condition. Any reference to condition in a catalogue
description or a condition report shall not amount to a full
accounting of condition. Condition reports prepared by Hindman
staff are provided as a convenience and may be requested from the
Department prior to bidding.
The absence of a posted condition report on the Hindman website or
in our catalogues should not be interpreted as commentary on an
item's condition. Prospective buyers are responsible for
inspecting a lot or sending their agent or conservator to inspect
the lot on their behalf, and for ensuring that they have
requested, received and understood any condition report provided
by Hindman.
Please email [email protected] for any additional information or questions you may have regarding this lot.