Lot 50
Attractive German Silver Mounted Full Stock Percussion Altered Kentucky Rifle, Attributed to Samuel Armstrong (Emmitsburg School, MD)
Sale 2030 - Arms, Armor and Militaria
Oct 23, 2024 10:00AM ET
Live / Cincinnati

Estimate
$4,000 - $6,000
Lot Description
Attractive German Silver Mounted Full Stock Percussion Altered Kentucky Rifle, Attributed to Samuel Armstrong (Emmitsburg School, MD)
About .52 caliber. 36" octagonal barrel. SN: NSN. Browned metal finish. Curled maple stock has a straight grip and carved cheekpiece to left side. Percussion rifle most likely converted from flintlock at some point, with notch rear sight and silver post front sight. Item features double set triggers, patchbox to left side, and a rifled barrel. Stock has 14 German silver escutcheons deeply engraved with scrollwork to both sides including six to forearm (three on both sides), four more elaborate escutcheons to left side of butt, one on top of wrist, one on right side of butt, one on comb, an engraved eagle to cheekpiece, and an engraved grip plate to bottom of forearm. Patchbox is very elaborate with 13 pierced sections and deep attractive scrollwork engravings. Brass fittings included faceted buttplate, thimbles, and triggerguard, as well as a wave pattern engraved toe plate with 5 screws, and a cheekpiece plate that appears to be very lightly engraved with a name in script (possibly Dxxxx S. William). Barrel is engraved with a name that appears to be Armstrong, preceded by two illegible initials (possibly J.H. or S.H.). Lock has illegible manufacturer markings and simple game scene engravings, possibly a commercial English lock and likely a replacement. Includes half of a more recent wood ramrod.

This rifle was most likely made by Samuel Armstrong, one of the sons/apprentices of master Emmitsburg School gunmaker John Armstrong. There is little known about Samuel Armstrong aside from that he was based in Frederick County Maryland and that he is known to have produced one other rifle with his name signed in script to the barrel (possibly the same one sold in 2023).

Unlike Samuel, John Armstrong's life is well documented by Kindig, as well as the Emmitsburg Historical Society, and while he was well known as a gunsmith working primarily in Maryland, he was originally from either Hanover or Cumberland County, Pennsylvania area. He is believed to have been apprenticed by legendary gunmaker George Schroyer, with his apprenticeship beginning in 1786 at the age of 14, and ending in 1793. Kindig also suggests that he may have been trained/influenced by Andrew Kopp, who was trained by George Eister of York County. An apprentice to John Armstrong named Nathaniel Rowe is documented as stating he worked constantly from 1793-1840, and took on many apprentices.

It is possible that this rifle was assembled from several rifles/parts at some point during the early percussion period or after. It has several style characteristics that are similar to "Golden Age" Kentucky rifles sold online, as well as schools of gunmakers detailed in Kindig's Thoughts on the Kentucky Rifle. During examination, it was noted that this rifle has forearm escutcheons that are similar to an Allen Armstrong rifle sold in 2011. However, the "National Road" patchbox style and silver escutcheons on the butt are also very similar to a school of gunmakers listed in Kindig's Thoughts (T. Allison, G. Kettering, and an unknown maker, p.532-538). These three gunmakers all used the same style of elaborate, heavily pierced and engraved patchboxes. They also carved their stocks with beautiful raised scrollwork very similar to the silver escutcheon shapes used on this rifle. Finally, the barrel plain script signature "Armstrong" appears very similar to how John Armstrong signed his barrels, but without the brass plate inlet. In addition to Armstrong, this rifle also shares similarities with gunmakers Andrew Kopp and Nathaniel Row of the Emmitsburg School. Kopp was an older contemporary of John Armstrong and is believed to have influenced his work. According to Kinding, Kopp was most likely trained trained by George Eister of York County.
This lot is located in Cincinnati.
Condition Report
Good to very good. Bore is dark with residue. Finish has a mottled dark brown/plum appearance overall due to finish loss, patina, pitting, and scratching. Barrel likely shortened at some point in time, likely by 6"-8". Wood stock possibly refurbished at some point, with crack repairs around triggerguard, what appears to be old glue or tar residue inside of lock cutaway, and light splintering/cracking to both sides of barrel/forearm. There are losses to wood around tang, lock, and forearm as well. Action is functional.

The physical condition of lots in our auctions can vary due to age, normal wear and tear, previous damage, and restoration/repair. All lots are sold "AS IS," in the condition they are in at the time of the auction, and we and the seller make no representation or warranty and assume no liability of any kind as to a lot's condition. Any reference to condition in a catalogue description or a condition report shall not amount to a full accounting of condition. Condition reports prepared by Hindman staff are provided as a convenience and may be requested from the Department prior to bidding.

The absence of a posted condition report on the Hindman website or in our catalogues should not be interpreted as commentary on an item's condition. Prospective buyers are responsible for inspecting a lot or sending their agent or conservator to inspect the lot on their behalf, and for ensuring that they have requested, received and understood any condition report provided by Hindman.

Please email [email protected] for any additional information or questions you may have regarding this lot.
Search